Look through our alphabetical list of categories

Cheese Stores in New York

Updated Oct 05 2014 04:43 PM EST with 34 listings
Cheese Stores in New York

Agata & Valentina

Cheese's from all over the world. Highly rated by Zagat NYC Market Place. Zagat's Marketplace '00
1505 First Ave., Yorkville NY 10021 79th St Upper East Side., Tel 212-452-0690
Fax: 212-452-0694

Alleva Dairy

"Homemade" Mozzarella and ricotta. Highly rated by Zagat NYC Market Place. Zagat's Marketplace '00
188 Grand St., Little Italy NY 10013 at Mulberry St., Tel 212-226-7990
Fax: 212-266-7990; Website: www

Cheese of the world

Good value and variety. Highly rated by Zagat NYC Market Place. Zagat's Marketplace '00
Queens, NY, Tel 718-263-1933

Cheese Unlimited

240 Ninth Ave., Chelsea NY 10001 Tel 212-691-1512
Fax: 212-627-8873

Citarella

Highly rated by Zagat NYC Market Place. Zagat's Marketplace '00
2135 Broadway, Upper West Side NY 10023 Tel 212-874-0383
Fax: 212-595-3738

Dean & Deluca

Well known source for the best quality and largest selection of breads, cheeses, coffee beans and all wonderful things edible. Highly rated by Zagat NYC Market Place. Zagat's Marketplace '00
560 Broadway, Soho NY 10012 Prince St., Tel 212-431-1691
Tel: 800-221-7714; Website: dean-deluca.com

Di Palo's Dairy Store

Rated number 1 for quality by Zagat NYC Market Place.
206 Grand St., Little Italy NY 10013 Tel 212-226-1033

E.A.T.

Good quality and excellent selection. Highly rated by Zagat NYC Market Place. Zagat's Marketplace '00
1064 Madison Ave., Upper East Side NY 10028 betw 80th & 81st St, Tel 212-772-0022
Fax: 212-628-1625; Website: elizabar.com

East Village Cheese

No exotic cheeses but unbeatable prices. Highly rated by Zagat NYC Market Place. Zagat's Marketplace '00
40 Third Ave., Greenwich Village NY 10003 Tel 212-477-2601
Fax: 212-228-1578

Eli's Manhattan

"Excellent choices". Highly rated by Zagat NYC Market Place. Zagat's Marketplace '00
1411 Third Ave., Yorkville NY betw 80th & 81st St, Tel 212-717-8100

Eli's Vinegar Factory

Highly rated by Zagat NYC Market Place.
431 E. 91st St., Yorkville NY 10128 betw 1st & York Ave , Tel 212-628-9608
Tel: 212-987-0885; Fax: 212-876-3421
Website: elizabar.com

Fairway

Lots of produce and cheeses; picnic baskets available. Highly rated by Zagat NYC Market Place. Zagat's Marketplace '00
2328 Twelfth Ave., Manhattanville NY 10023 Hudson River & 132nd St, Tel 212-234-3883
Website: fairwaymarket.com

Foods of New York Walking & Tasting Tours

Try the Fall Cheeses tour and sample the fine cheeses at Murray's Cheese Shop on Bleeker.
Seventh Ave., West Village NY Tel 732-636-4650
Website: foodsofny.com

Gourmet Garage - Flatiron District

Highly rated by Zagat NYC Market Place.
117 Seventh Ave., Flatiron District NY betw. W 10th & Christopher St, Tel 212-699-5980
Website: gourmetgarage.com

Gourmet Garage - Upper West Side

2567 Broadway, Upper West Side NY 10025 btw. 96th & 97th St., Tel 212-663-0656

Grace's Marketplace

Top quality, fresh, and reliable. Highly rated by Zagat NYC Market Place. Zagat's marketplace '00
1237 Third Ave., Uptown East NY 10021 (71st St.), Tel 212-737-0600

Greek House Foods

"Good cheese and olives". Highly rated by Zagat NYC Market Place. Zagat's marketplace '00
Queens, NY, Tel 718-545-5252

Ideal Cheese

"Unbelievable variety of excellent cheese". Highly rated by Zagat NYC Market Place. Zagat's Marketplace '00
1205 Second Ave., Uptown East NY 10021 Tel 212-688-7579
Fax: 212-223-1245; Website: idealcheese.com

Joe's Dairy

"Best smoked Mozzerella in town, at fari prices". Highly rated by Zagat NYC Market Place. Zagat's marketplace '00
156 Sullivan St., Soho NY 10012 Tel 212-677-8780

La Fromagerie

"Unpredictable array of cheese". Highly rated by Zagat NYC Market Place. Zagat's marketplace '00
1374 Madison Ave., Carnegie Hill NY Tel 212-534-8923

La Marca Cheese Shop

"Small but great selection of quality cheese". Highly rated by Zagat NYC Market Place. Zagat's marketplace '00
161 E. 22nd St., Gramercy Park NY 10010 Tel 212-673-7920
Fax: 212-982-1482

Latticini Barese

"Finest imports along with moist creamy mozzarella". Highly rated by Zagat NYC Market Place. Zagat's marketplace '00
Brooklyn, NY, Tel 212-625-8694

Lioni Latticini Inc

Speciality goods and sandwich shop, offering mozzarella and ricotta shipped in daily.
7803 Fifthteenth Ave., Brooklyn NY 11228 Tel 718-232-1411

Murray's Cheese Shop

"Top quality and Fair Prices". Highly rated by Zagat NYC Market Place. Zagat's marketplace '00
257 Bleeker St., Greenwich Village NY 10014 Tel 212-243-3289
Fax: 212-243-5001; Toll-Free: 888-692-4339
Website: murrayscheese.com

Nicola's Gourmet

"Impossible to beat for quality and price". Highly rated by Zagat NYC Market Place. Zagat's marketplace '00
997 First Ave., Sutton Place NY Tel 212-753-9275

Ninth Avenue Cheese Market

Over 600 varieties to choose from. Rated by Zagat NYC Market Place.
615 Ninth Ave., Clinton NY 10036 Tel 212-397-4700
Fax: 212-757-8265

O Sweet Cheese

Offers cheese from France, Norway, Italy, Denmark, and England. Rated by Zagat NYC Market Place.
141 Third Ave., Gramercy Park NY Tel 212-477-1221

Petak's

"Often exotic choices but limited selection". Rated by Zagat NYC Market Place. Zagat's marketplace '00
1244 Madison Ave., Carnegie Hill NY 10028 Tel 212-722-7711
Fax: 212-722-4498

Piazza Mercato

Speciality Food store, great homemade sausages, sopressata, capicola and prosciutto. Selection of imported cheeses, pastas, oils and vinegars.
9204 Third Ave., Brooklyn NY 11209 Tel 718-513-0071

Ronnybrook Farms Dairy

"Fresh off the farm cheeses". Highly rated by Zagat NYC Market Place. Zagat's marketplace '00
75 Ninth Ave., Chelsea NY betw 15th & 16th St, Tel 212-741-6455
Tel: 800-772-6455

Russo's Mozzarella & Pasta

Brooklyn, NY, Tel 718-369-2874

Russo's Mozzarella & Pasta - East Village

"Flawless Mozzarella". Highly rated by Zagat NYC Market Place.
344 E. 11th St., East Village NY 10003 Tel 212-254-7452

Todaro Brothers

"Nice selection of cheese, foreign and domestic". Highly rated by Zagat NYC Market Place. Zagat's marketplace '00
555 Second Ave., Kips Bay NY 10016 betw 30th & 31st St), Tel 212-532-0633
Fax: 212-689-1679; Website: todarobros.com

Zabar's

"Phenominal variety". Highly rated by Zagat NYC Market Place.
2245 Broadway, Upper West Side NY 10024 betw 80th & 81st St, Tel 212-496-1234
Info in Spanish: 212-787-2000; Toll-Free: 800-697-6301
E-mail: info@zabars.com; Website: zabars.com